You forgot Walker Boone, who voiced Mario in the shows following Super Show.

That being said, considering I actually cosplayed as Lou Albano’s Mario, I’ll go with the captain 🫡.

Bob Hoskins, though I admit, my decision is partly colored by his many other awesome roles.

Bob Hopkins. Though I respect the Captain, Bob will always have a special place in my heart. The way he finally came around to the world and used the mushroom in the end was great 😃

No Charles Martinet? Aight, Imma head out