Wow look at that, based EU state respecting its citizens privacy and totally not pulling a totalitarian China move.

What? The Heise article talks about how both apps access location APIs, but UEFA only publicly acknowledges that the second app tracks. The issue here is that the ticket app tracks, but UEFA says it doesn’t. The issue here is that UEFA is lying.

Looking at the permissions on the German Google Play store will obviously show that location is not used by the ticket app, because the entire issue being reported is that location is accessed without the knowledge of the users and without being reported in the app stores. This is why I asked how you checked, you need to check the app with something like Exodus or rev eng it and look at the actual api calls made in the source code.

I feel like I’m taking crazy pills. Do you just not believe that developers could lie, either directly or by omission, about what data their app collects?

When and how did you check this? The following quotes are taken from the posted article, emphasis mine.

UEFA told us that all location data is anonymized and only tracked on match days, starting six hours before kick-off and ending six hours after the match. The data aids in managing fan flow and ensuring timely updates via push notifications. UEFA’s spokesperson said this location data is “an invaluable tool” in maintaining safety.

For starters, we are reluctant to believe that both Bayerischer Rundfunk (who made the video in collaboration with the actual people involved in the monitoring process) and Heise would have mislabeled the UEFA Ticket app instead of saying it is the EURO 2024 app.

As it stands, Stack Diary cannot independently verify what the insides of the Ticket app look like because the tickets have been sold out since early June, and you are required a QR code to see what the app looks like. If you have more information to give, please get in touch with us.

According to Heise, the app requires explicit GPS permissions, which are not disclosed on the Android or iOS privacy pages for the UEFA Mobile Tickets application. When checking with Exodus, both the Tickets and the EURO app require “ACCESS_FINE_LOCATION” and “ACCESS_COARSE_LOCATION” permissions, which allow an app to access precise location data using GPS, Wi-Fi, and mobile networks.

The entire point of this story is that the UEFA ticket app requires access to location functions without telling the user. Have you either used a tool like exodus or extracted the source code of the ticket app from the apk and manually reviewed it?

Also, you sound like you’re under the assumption that users reported this. You realize that this was originally reported by the German IT news outlet heise.de and not by complaints from random users right?

You seem to be operating on a mistaken understanding of the EU. While the EU works to protect citizens within the EU from being monitored, tracked, and monetized by foreign entities and private EU companies, they have no concept of personal privacy of citizens within the EU from the EU governments themselves. If the data is being sent to the police, it is legal. See the EU Councils position on encryption and what level of access law enforcement within EU nations should have.