• kava@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    24 days ago

    You should be supporting Ukraine because of democracy, sovereignty, and the security guarantees you gave them by signing the Budapest memorandum, remember, when Ukraine gave up its nukes.

    Stop spreading misinformation. Read the Budapest Memorandum again, please. There were no security guarantees given by the US.

    I believe in democracy and sovereignty - the US state does not.

    and that’s another reason why you won’t be dropping Ukraine

    What happens to Ukraine does not ultimately matter to US power. Right now it’s a convenient place to test new weapons, get battlefield intel, inject some nice cash into defense contractors.

    But the real focus is on the East.

    All this, ultimately, just amounts to a French win

    See, I view the total opposite. It’s interesting how people can see the same thing and get different conclusions

    After WW2, Europe was essentially made subservient to the US. The threat of the Soviets was very real and the US was the only one that could keep the Soviets at bay. Therefore, NATO was formed. Cue the infamous quote from the first General Secretary - the reason for NATO was “to keep the Americans in, the Germans down, and the Russians out”

    After 1991 there was a real hope that Russia could integrate with Europe. No more USSR, no more threat, right? No more reason for NATO, no more reason for hostility. Imagine a Europe where Russia was integrated into the security blanket. Europe would become a superpower by its own right - no need to bow down to the Americans. There was decades of slow attempts at integration (for example with energy like natural gas pipelines)

    But that vision never materialized and after a gradual decline in relations, Russia invading Ukraine was the best gift Russia has ever given to the Americans.

    It basically started the process of a permanent decoupling of Russia from Europe and it forced the Europeans into the arms of the Americans. Now, Europe has no choice but to align with the Americans.

    This is the reason you start seeing populists like Trump start using harsh rhetoric about NATO. “Freeloading Europeans now need to pay their fair share”, etc.

    The reason why Americans can get away with it now, where they couldn’t before, is because Europe has no choice.