I recently got a Sony prs 600 e reader from 2009. The battery is at the end of its life (It lasts about 3 days with heavy reading, and a couple weeks without reading). No backlight, no Wi-Fi, just an SD card that I can load epub files and small PDFs. The screen is slow and the contrast isn’t the best. The “touch screen” is the old resistive type where you really need to press with your nail or a stylus. Despite all those flaws, it’s fantastic. It’s just good enough for reading books.
I read with large text so I don’t even need to put on glasses, and it’s easier to read than an actual book. Combined with Anna’s archive, I’m reading more than I ever have before. No Wi-Fi nd slow screen make the experience feel closer to an actual book than a smartphone. It’s great to just have a device do one thing without distractions popping up every minute.
It’s all old technology, but it’s so rare to see anyone with an e-reader. Probably because they’re still expensive and designed to microtransact the fuck out of you.
So do you think there could be a simple open source e reader? I see pine64 is making the “pinenote”, but it’s still just the developer version, it’s expensive, doesn’t have an sd card, and looks like it’s trying to be a lot more than an reader. Maybe it’ll come down in cost, or they’ll release a simpler version? The biggest obstacle for making an e-reader seems to be the screen, so maybe the pinenote’s screen could become something of a standard.
Or maybe I’m overthinking it, because there’s already so many old Kindles and nooks out there that could be improved with a new battery and maybe new firmware too.
Thoughts?
Kobo e-readers are known to be pretty hackable and many of their models can be used with ‘KoReader’ an open source e-reading OS/app
Very Cool, I didn’t know about these. Maybe just keeping readers out of landfills is the way to go.
You might be in a better position than you realize! I see two great options for you:
Option 1.
Here’s a new battery for your reader, it’s about $13.
Here’s a battery replacement video. It’s amazingly simple! I forgot what wonderful times the aughts were for diy repair.
Option 2
If you’re feeling a little more carefree and like saying “damn the aesthetics!” Especially when you mention keeping readers out of landfills:
Buy a broken eReader off of eBay that still turns on and scavenge the battery. Most of them seem to use the same voltage. If the battery you source doesn’t fit, make a notch in the side of your reader and tape the new battery to the back or whatever. Donate the remainder to your local Makerspace.
If you end up enjoying your little rebellious repairs, buy bulk non-functioning eReaders and try using them to repair each other. Donate the functioning ones to your local library and the non-functioning parts to your local Makerspace.
Dope! I think I will get that
Damn I have a Kobo and didn’t know this. Will definitely be doing this
The reason e-readers are still so expensive is because the company that makes the displays (E-ink) has a patent on them. The Pinenote website says it uses an E-ink panel so I’m assuming that’s where they’re sourcing from
A few years ago there was a potential competitor in the space (ClearInk) but…it looks like their website is gone and their Facebook page hasn’t been updated in 5 years
Ah, thanks. That makes sense. I knew it was the screens, but didn’t realize it’s a whack patent issue
Yeah…I guess the original patent expired in 2018 but you know how patents go… “We changed one tiny thing and patented it again”
Thoughts?
Cool nails.
I like the Kobo readers they work very well. No bullshit or anything.
You don’t even ever need to connect it to WiFi.
They are also much nicer than an ancient tablet form 2009.
There’s already projects going for open source firmware for pre existing hardware, such as inkbox and KoReader
I’m also watching the open book project. I’m hoping that supporting it will enable things to progress to the point where it gets in the hands of schoolchildren in developing countries
Not open source, but I use a Kobo Libra 2 with KoReader installed, and use Calibre to manage my library.
Though if waste is your concern, I would see about replacing the battery.
Thought you could replace the OS to the open-source ones.
I had that exact same model 15 years ago. It got stolen and I’m still not over it. I got basic Kobo readers instead; they work fine with Calibre and any ebook you can get. I don’t touch Amazon with a ten-foot pole, and I never use the Kobo account you have to create when buying the device.
But I’d give somebody’s left arm to have the Sony back. It was perfect.
I don’t remember the name of it but there is one. The only problem is it only takes text files iirc. also last I checked it was a PCB sandwich type device with open sides
Epub are the de facto open source standard. That’s like a “MP3 Player” only playing Wav.
How do you blunder it that bad?
"The Open Book is my long-standing attempt to design a comprehensible and accessible e-book reader that you can build yourself (or at least have manufactured affordably). The current edition is something I’m calling the “Abridged” or “Developer Preview” edition. It’s designed to be incredibly simple: there are 7 through-hole and 14 surface mount components, nearly all in a chunky 1206 package that’s easy to hand solder. The tradeoff is that it has no LiPo charging circuit; instead it uses AAA batteries, making it a bit more chunky than previous versions of the book.
The goal with this version is to get hardware in hands so we can start hacking on firmware."
https://www.oddlyspecificobjects.com/projects/openbook/
So:
- This is a hobby / project of love
- The current focus is on hardware
I’m sure that the eventual plan is to support ePub.
I’m not sure it will ever get there, because it’s not a well resourced project, but I personally don’t like criticizing one person’s efforts, which they are making freely available.
What part of Op’s comment led you to this specific project? He could not even recall the name.
“I was referring to open book reader…”
The lack of capitalization, and the project name that could just as easily be a descriptor, made me miss it at first too.
What are you even talking about? I was referring to open book reader which others already mentioned which should have been easy enough to realize by PCB sandwich. Unless things have developed significantly since I last checked in on the project it does not take epub as is and needs to be txt (got auto corrected to text in previous post).
I was talking about the file format only allowing .txt being a blunder.
Epub is a drm free format with no royalties. And it’s the de facto standard all over the internet.
Oh I see that makes sense now and is the reason I didn’t jump on the project when I first heard about it.
Also, I tried to just make a text post but voyager wouldn’t let me
The photo is a good added content for your post imo
True. Gotta let the people know we (communists) out here
Interesting thoughts. Personally I use a pocketbook to read. It’s been pretty good with a red light backlight for the dark(that is gentle for the eyes before sleep) a built-in dictionary and the ability to export notes from books. This is everything I need in an ereader. Unfortunately it has a browser, some unnecessary small games and some other features that anyone who buys relatively expensive ereaders(hence is committed to reading books) won’t possibly ever need.
But the unnecessary features won’t bother you too much. The UI is clean and easy to navigate.
Pocketbook is not open source or anything, but at least I don’t fund Amazon’s monopoly, it’s a smaller company and it’s definitely value for money imo.
ability to export notes from books
This is something I can’t do on my Kobo and annoys me. Which pocketbook do you have?
It’s a pocketbook era, but this feature will work for any pocketbook model that can highlight text, because the notes are exported through the pocketbook cloud in the app/website.
There is actually an open source eReader, openbook https://www.oddlyspecificobjects.com/projects/openbook/
Unfortunately, the current screen it uses is not being made anymore. People have stated that they have gotten other screens to work, but no official instructions on using them yet
I don’t know about open hardware but Inkbox is a FOSS OS which can be installed on Kobo devices. I’d like to try it out.
Did you read it?
I just got an used Paperwhite. It was I think 50€. I never connected it to internet, I just transfer stuff with Calibre
Cheaper and simplier devices can do that, I agree. Lowering gradations of grey can hurt comic books readers but won’t hurt book reading routine that much. WiFi and bluetooth are convinient, but at the same time they hurts bettery life too much, so it’s better to go without them. Sleeping or turned off mode is kinda stupid for it rerenders the whole page to show the default image on cheap devices - the goal as I see it is to minimize rerendering and thus turn off these completely. Touchscreens are rather useless and they too use power – a couple of physical buttons cover most needs. It’s just the UI on most of them is very unfriendly, judging by chinese ones I had used, and open-sourcing it can save us a lot of headache. Backlit books though are here to be, and there should be a hotkey to turn it off and on, so one can resd it comfortably at any time and quickly avoid energy waste. Having SD card for everything exluding OS instead of internal memory would probably make it cheaper. And as we probably expecting schools to make them popular, there should be a dock for multiple devices to rapidly upload one collection of files to a dozen of devices.
